Xtreme Trophy Fishing Customer Reviews

Name: Xtreme Trophy Fishing
Brand: Xtreme Trophy Fishing
Rating: 5 (20 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 20
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Milton Nieto consistently delivers exceptional alligator gar fishing adventures, with customers landing monster fish up to 6 feet long even in challenging conditions. His expertise shines through as he puts anglers directly on giant gar using the right gear and techniques, making bucket list dreams come true for both first-timers and experienced fishermen seeking that true adventure factor. Milton brings genuine Texas hospitality and patience to every trip, taking time to explain each step and answer questions from curious kids and adults alike. Families especially appreciate his skill with young anglers - one father watched his 16-year-old son land a massive gar that still lights him up in conversation, while another praised how fantastic Milton was with his nine-year-old throughout their full-day adventure.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Alligator Gar

Monster Fish

Texas Hospitality

Bucket List

Family Friendly

Expert Angling

Challenging Conditions

Full-Day Trips

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Eduardo Soto

May 12, 2025

Trip - Trinity River Alligator Gar Full-Day Guided Trip on May 12, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Had an awesome time out on the water with Carlos! Took me and my coworkers out to catch alligator gar and we landed some monsters. Super knowledgeable and made the whole trip easy and fun. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great fishing experience!

Was this helpful ?

Kyle Just

May 5, 2025

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on May 5, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Had a great trip with captian Milton. His communication was fantastic from start to finish, and he was very knowledgeable. He provided great tips and coaching to help us land multiple big fish. My wife and I had a great time hanging out with him on the boat for the day.

Was this helpful ?

Kim Tindell

April 28, 2025

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on April 28, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

If you’re looking to hook a monster fish and have a blast doing it, Milton is your guy. My buddy Phil and I have been fishing for alligator gar for a few years now. We learned more in an hour than we have in our years of fishing together. Milton knows where to go, has great gear, and a sense of humor to keep you entertained between bites. His boat was clean and well stocked. We cought multiple big ones and hooked a 6 foot monster gar, Milton's expertise made sure we landed them and helped us with some great photos. I cant recommend him enough! We'll definitely be booking him again.

Was this helpful ?

Neil P

March 23, 2025

Trip - on March 23, 2025

This was my first time going after alligator gar. Milton put me on a giant if you want a true adventure go with Milton. He’s a lot of fun to go fishing with and he will put you on a monster gar. He definitely brings the awesome factor to alligator gar fishing 🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊🐊!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Was this helpful ?

Kendal M

March 22, 2025

Trip - on March 22, 2025

I took my son, an avid bass fisherman, out for his 16th birthday, and he ended up landing a Gar close to 6 feet long. Even now, he lights up every time the trip comes up in conversation.

Was this helpful ?

Steve E

February 12, 2025

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on February 18, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

I had a blast fishing with Capt. Milton. He is an awesome guide with the right combination of fishing knowledge, drive to succeed and customer service. He worked hard and made several adjustments to put me on the "Monster" I was after. I take multiple guided fishing trips a year and I know how hard it is to choose the right guide. Rest assure, If you choose Xtreme Trophy Fishing Guide Service, you made the right choice.

Was this helpful ?

William Sedgwick

February 10, 2025

Trip - Trinity River Alligator Gar Full-Day Guided Trip on February 10, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Had a great time catching Alligator Gar with Captain Milton. 3 of us went and we were able to land a fish. He was very engaging answering all our questions and knew what to do in order to increase our chances of getting a fish. Had such a great experience last time I booked Captain Milton again. I took my buddy and his son and we had a great time. I am going to continue booking Captain Milton again and again for my friends and family to get the experience of catching monsters

Was this helpful ?

Ian Clancy

January 19, 2025

Trip - Trinity River Alligator Gar Full-Day Guided Trip on January 19, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Something g that I’ve been wanting to do since I was a kid was fish for an alligator gar ... when I found myself in Texas with my fiancé, I knew this was the time to do it. When I first spoke with Milton months prior ... I knew I was in for a good time! Despite astronomical flood conditions on the Trinity River ... Milton was able to navigate it all safely and get us on the fish. I was so happy to beat my PB with my 7 foot gar and my fiancé reeling in her own 6 foot monster. Don’t settle for any guide ... Go for the one who can handle any conditions 🔥

Was this helpful ?

Michael Edwards

January 7, 2025

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on January 7, 2025

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

I have now been on multiple trips with Capt. Milton. Every trip is top notch. Capt. Milton truly knows where to find the Biggest Alligator Gar and Catfish.

Was this helpful ?

Todd Covington

December 16, 2024

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on December 16, 2024

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

First time out with Capt Milton. He was polite, on time and professional. Got along great with my 14 year old and gave him extra attention. He also put is on the monsters! I highly recommend him.

Was this helpful ?

Rodney Alexander

October 21, 2024

Trip - Trinity River Alligator Gar Full-Day Guided Trip on October 21, 2024

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

a year ago This was definitely a fishing trip of a lifetime!!!!! Milton was awesome and really knows his fishing. We landed 7 fish with 5 of them 100LB plus, with the biggest being a 7 footer with a 36” girth. Call and book you a trip of a lifetime.

Was this helpful ?

Allan Braxdale

October 21, 2024

Trip - Pro Angler Gar Hunt Full Day Fishing In Trinity River on October 21, 2024

7:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Milton and his team are excellent guides. Have fished with Milton and XTF several times and they always put us on fish! If you want to catch giants call Milton!

Was this helpful ?

Your Gateway to Xtreme Trophy Fishing Adventures

About Xtreme Trophy Fishing Business Reviews

Welcome to the Xtreme Trophy Fishing Customer Reviews page—where guest stories bring the experience to life. Hear directly from anglers who’ve joined Captain Milton Nieto and his crew on unforgettable guided trips along the Trinity River. These reviews offer genuine insights into the challenge of targeting massive Alligator Gar, the excitement of fishing with heavy tackle, and the connection built with fellow anglers on the water.

Each testimonial highlights the care, professionalism, and expertise we bring to every outing. Whether it’s your first time or you’re a returning guest, these reflections show why so many choose Xtreme Trophy Fishing for a memorable day on the river.

Xtreme Trophy Fishing Customer Reviews are shared by our guests following guided trips on the Trinity River. We’re committed to delivering a top-tier experience with every outing, and our customer feedback reflects that dedication.